PromptRiskDBThreat intelligence atlas

Lower performance for some languages and social groups

AI Risk

"LMs perform less well in some languages (Joshi et al., 2021; Ruder, 2020)...LM that more accurately captures the language use of one group, compared to another, may result in lower-quality language technologies for the latter. Disadvantaging users based on such traits may be particularly pernicious because attributes such as social class or education background are not typically covered as ‘protected characterist...

Overview

A source-backed snapshot of this AI risk.

"LMs perform less well in some languages (Joshi et al., 2021; Ruder, 2020)...LM that more accurately captures the language use of one group, compared to another, may result in lower-quality language technologies for the latter. Disadvantaging users based on such traits may be particularly pernicious because attributes such as social class or education background are not typically covered as ‘protected characteristics’ in anti-discrimination law."

Techniques0Attack methods connected to this risk.
Mitigations0Defenses that may help with related attacks.
Records2Source records unified into this concept.

Risk profile

How the MIT AI Risk Repository categorizes this risk.

Domain1. Discrimination & Toxicity
Subdomain1.3 > Unequal performance across groups
Entity2 - AI
Intent2 - Unintentional
Timing2 - Post-deployment
CategoryDiscrimination, Exclusion and Toxicity; Risk area 1: Discrimination, Hate speech and Exclusion
SubcategoryLower performance for some languages and social groups

Merged risk records

Source records unified into this canonical risk concept.

2 recordsView all →

MITRISK-Weidinger2021-17.01.04 - Lower performance for some languages and social groups

"LMs perform less well in some languages (Joshi et al., 2021; Ruder, 2020)...LM that more accurately captures the language use of one group, compared to another, may result in lower-quality language technologies for the latter. Disadvantaging users based on such traits may be particularly pernicious because attributes such as social class or education background are not typically covered as ‘protected characteristics’ in anti-discrimination law."

Domain1. Discrimination & ToxicitySubdomain1.3 > Unequal performance across groupsSourceEthical and social risks of harm from language modelsYear2021

MITRISK-Weidinger2022-16.01.04 - Lower performance for some languages and social groups

"LMs are typically trained in few languages, and perform less well in other languages [95, 162]. In part, this is due to unavailability of training data: there are many widely spoken languages for which no systematic efforts have been made to create labelled training datasets, such as Javanese which is spoken by more than 80 million people [95]. Training data is particularly missing for languages that are spoken by groups who are multilingual and can use a technology in English, or for languages spoken by groups who are not the primary target demographic for new technologies."

Domain1. Discrimination & ToxicitySubdomain1.3 > Unequal performance across groupsSourceTaxonomy of Risks posed by Language ModelsYear2022

Mitigations

Defenses that may help with related attacks.

No propagated mitigations. No defense is available through the connected attack methods.

Source evidence

Research source for this risk, when available.